Are the First Growths Over-rated? Bob Ross, New Jersey, 11-Oct-2005 17:47

One more for the road... Covert Harris, 15-Oct-2005 12:11

There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that Bordeaux is the empire ... Bob Ross, New Jersey, 16-Oct-2005 08:20

That's right... Covert Harris, 16-Oct-2005 12:03

One more for the road... Steve Plotnicki, 15-Oct-2005 14:54

You’ve made my day, Steve... Covert Harris, 15-Oct-2005 17:57

Back in 1855, No.. JJB, 14-Oct-2005 16:36

Well, back in 1855, they were rated by price! [e] Jason Brandt Lewis (Berkeley, CA), 14-Oct-2005 22:58

Much of the Media Steve Plotnicki, 14-Oct-2005 14:28

Just like the zillions of women... Covert Harris, 15-Oct-2005 18:21

Slightly Different Steve Plotnicki, 16-Oct-2005 13:34

How about this Walt Carpenter (St. Louis), 14-Oct-2005 15:35

True, and it's why ... Paul B., Ontario, Canada, 15-Oct-2005 02:26

How about this Steve Plotnicki, 14-Oct-2005 16:22

From the author of... Jamie Goode, 14-Oct-2005 13:44

I'm shocked, Jamie Thor Iverson, 14-Oct-2005 18:28

Over-rated how? David R. Laws (Maryland, USA), 13-Oct-2005 00:33

You would think... dave c., 12-Oct-2005 15:43

Something I've always wondered Thor Iverson, 12-Oct-2005 18:42

Three editors? Paul B., Ontario, Canada, 12-Oct-2005 19:13

It was only two editors from my fingers to print... Thor Iverson, 12-Oct-2005 20:44

Seems to be a tradition, Dave. Frank Prial is a role model, I suppose. Bob Ross, New Jersey, 12-Oct-2005 16:32

Yes Peter Ruhrberg (Saarbrücken), 12-Oct-2005 13:43

Who hires these clowns? Nathan Smyth, 12-Oct-2005 07:09

Those are Bordeaux, right? Joe Perry (Boston), 11-Oct-2005 23:24

Are the First Growths Over-rated? Agostino Berti, 11-Oct-2005 20:53

Bad Bottle is my theory CMM, 11-Oct-2005 20:25

Poor standards..... O W Holmes, MIchigan, USA, 11-Oct-2005 19:07

Are the First Growths Over-rated? Larry Moss, 11-Oct-2005 18:50

Why wait? Craig(NZ), 12-Oct-2005 10:20

Forgot one more comment Walt Carpenter (St. Louis), 11-Oct-2005 18:40

Ridiculous article Walt Carpenter (St. Louis), 11-Oct-2005 18:35

Asenine Jim Dove, 11-Oct-2005 18:02

How much of a role do expectations play? Sam Platt, 12-Oct-2005 19:33

A lot; so does palate preference Jenise, 13-Oct-2005 17:33

Was it a blind tasting? (e) Sam Platt, 14-Oct-2005 17:12

Partial Jenise, 14-Oct-2005 17:25

The $15 Bordeaux and Chateau Latour Hoke Harden, 11-Oct-2005 18:14

Yet "journalists" love to do this David M. Bueker, 11-Oct-2005 18:26

Yet "journalists" love to do this Craig W, 11-Oct-2005 21:29

Very true Paul B., Ontario, Canada, 12-Oct-2005 14:34

case in point Craig W, 11-Oct-2005 23:29

Yes, but not in the way the article says David M. Bueker, 11-Oct-2005 17:54